We consider the various legal forms of social enterprise activities. All these structures require specialist advice, so, if you are considering such a business in the London area we, at BRM, can assist you.
A social enterprise entity is a business with primarily social objectives. Any surpluses made are reinvested into the main principle of that entity (or into the community) rather than maximising profit for shareholders. Examples of types of objectives are regeneration of the local environmental area, promoting climate change awareness and training for disadvantaged people. There are various legal forms that should be considered when setting up this type of entity. Which one you choose will depend upon what the social enterprise actually does and the style of management of those running it.
The possible options available are as follows:
- Limited company
- Unincorporated association
- Community interest company (CIC)
- Charitable incorporated organisation (CIO)
- Co-operative or community benefit society
A limited company is a separate legal entity from its members and gives them limited liability. A limited company set up with a social purpose needs to set out its objectives which can also include commercial objectives. There are two choices of limited companies for social enterprise entities, a company limited by shares and a company limited by guarantee. In the case of a company limited by shares, dividends can be paid to the shareholders.
Limited company accounts need to be filed at Companies House and consideration needs to be given as to whether an audit is required.
If the limited company’s objectives are exclusively charitable and for the public benefit it may also be set up as a charity. Where this is the case the company will need to consider whether it needs to register with the Charity Commission. If it is a charity then it will need to follow Charities Act 2011 and the Charity Commission will require the submission of Annual Returns. In return, however it will have the benefits of being a charity such as potentially qualifying for a number of tax exemptions and reliefs on income and gains, and on profits for some activities.
Trusts are unincorporated bodies which do not distribute profits. The trust is set up as a legal entity which governs how its assets are to be used and as such can hold property and other assets for the community. Trustees act on behalf of the community in looking after the assets but it is important to note that the trust does not have its own legal identity The trustees are therefore liable for the trust’s liabilities.
Trust deeds are set up to protect the trust’s objectives. The trust is able to write an asset lock into its rules in order to secure assets for its intended community.
Like limited companies trusts can also be charities. The same points which are noted above for charitable limited companies should be considered for charitable trusts.
The simplest form for a social enterprise entity is an unincorporated association and it should be used when a number of individuals come together for a common ‘social’ purpose. There are very few formalities to setting up this way which is the key advantage. The members can set their own rules and a management committee is elected to run the entity on behalf of any members it may have. Associations are also able to carry out commercial activities.
The problem with the unincorporated association is that it has no separate legal identity. If there are any debts, the members are legally liable to pay those debts down to their last worldly possession. This type of entity is not likely to be suitable if you wish to employ staff, raise finance, take on leases or purchase property, apply for grants or enter into contractual arrangements.
Like limited companies and trusts, unincorporated associations can also be charities. The same points which are noted above for charitable limited companies should be considered for charitable unincorporated associations.
Community interest company (CIC)
These are specific limited companies that provide benefits to the community and the legal form has only been available since 2005. The reason behind the development of CICs was the lack of legal structures for non-charitable social enterprises. They can be set up as either companies limited by shares or companies limited by guarantee and thus have the benefits of limited liability. CICs need to be registered and comply with the CIC Regulations. They need to pass the ‘community interest test’ before they can register as CICs. Thus the main difference compared to other companies is that they are operating for the benefit of the community and not for the benefit of shareholders. An existing company can be converted to a CIC although a CIC cannot hold charitable status.
Like trusts, they have an asset lock which restricts profit distribution in certain circumstances and ensures that the assets are used for the community purpose. On winding up a CIC, all of the assets must be transferred to another similar asset-locked body.
A key advantage of a CIC (rather than a charity) is that the directors of a CIC can be remunerated (charity trustees generally are not remunerated). They are also not as heavily regulated (although are still regulated under a ‘light touch’ regime). They obviously do not have the taxation advantages that charities are entitled to and they have to file a community interest report annually with the CIC regulator (which is made available publicly).
Charitable incorporated organisation (CIO)
Since early 2013, the Charity Commission (the charity regulator for England and Wales) has started to register CIOs. CIOs have benefits similar to a limited company charity. This means that the members and trustees are usually personally safeguarded from the financial liabilities of the charity and that the charity has its own legal personality which means trustees do not have to take out contracts in their own names. CIOs do not have to register with Companies House but they do need to register with the Charity Commission.
In Scotland, SCIOs (Scottish Charitable Incorporated Organisations) have been available for a number of years now.
Co-operative or community benefit society
Community benefit societies (BenComs) are incorporated registered societies which operate for the benefit of the community in which they operate. They must be able to demonstrate their social objectives and these must continue to be met. Registration is with the Financial Conduct Authority for an applicable fee which will depend upon its rules.
BenComs are not the same as co-operatives as these operate primarily for the benefit of members. Depending on how they distribute profits and what activities they undertake, co-operatives can also be social enterprise entities.
How we can help
All of the above social enterprise entity structures require specialist advice so, if you are considering such a business in the London area we, at BRM, can assist you. We will be happy to discuss your plans and the most appropriate structure with you. The most appropriate structure will depend on a number of factors including consideration of taxation implications, the legal entity, regulation and management style.